UPSTATE
CLINTON COUNTY
NURSING HOMES
Restraints - Wrongful Death - Survival Damages
Nursing facility's patient
suffocated in bed mishap
SETTLEMENT |
$190,000 |
CASE |
Ralph D'Aust as Executor of the Estate of |
|
Lottie M. D'Aust, Deceased v. Champlain |
|
Vally Physicians Hospital Medical Center, |
|
No. 759/05 |
COURT |
Clinton Supreme |
JUDGE |
Kevin K. Ryan |
DATE |
3/17/2010 |
|
|
PLAINTIFF |
|
ATTORNEY(S) |
William L. Nikas, Hudson Falls, NY |
DEFENSE |
Thomas W. Plimpton, Stafford, Piller, |
ATTORNEY(S) |
Murnane, Plimpton, Kelleher & Trombley, |
|
PLLC, Plattsburgh, NY |
FACTS & ALLEGATIONS On Oct. 28, 2003, plaintiff's decedent Lottie D'Aust, an 83-year-old woman with end-stage dementia, was sleeping in a bed in a skilled nursing facility at Champlain Valley Physicians Hospital Medical Center, in Plattsburgh. During the night, she slid out of bed and got trapped between the bed and bedrail, with her face down against the mattress. She suffocated.
Ralph D' Aust, acting as the executor of the estate of Lottie D'Aust, sued the Champlain Valley Physicians Hospital Medical Center. He alleged that the hospital's nursing home was negligent in its care for the patient.
Plaintiff's counsel contended that the hospital failed to remove the bedrails from Ms. D'Aust's bed. He argued that there was no need form them to be on the decedent's bed and that they should have been removed sooner. Plaintiff's counsel also argued that the defendant failed to have monitors placed on the decedent's bed, which could have signaled an alarm as soon as D'Aust had a problem. He contended thatif the monitor had been in place, the hospital's staff could have been alerted to a problem sooner and possibly saved her life. Plaintiff's counsel argued that Ms. D'Aust's death was preventable and foreseeable, but that the defendant was negligent in its care of her.
Champlain Valley Physicians Hospital contended that it was in the process of removing bedrails from several beds there and that D'Aust's bed was scheduled to have its bedrails removed. Defense counsel called a manufacturer of the hospital bed to testify that the beds and bedrails in question were previously tested and found to be safe, pursuant to FDA guidelines.
The defendant's geriatrics expert testified that the use of monitors in a nursing home is not the standard of care because they could be more problematic than they are worth. He asserted that alarms on the monitors can go off for a variety of reasons - not just because the patient is in trouble. He opined that this could confuse the patient in a nursing facility and that the frequency of the alarms could cause them to be ignored by the nursing staff. The expert claimed that he doesn't use monitors at the facility he works at for the same reason.
INJURIES/DAMAGES
asphyxia; death
D'Aust was asphyxiated, resulting in death.Plaintiff's counsel contended that D' Aust had a few minutes of conscious pain and suffering and that it would have been a terrifying and horrific way to die. The estate sought recovery for D' Aust's conscious pain and suffering.
Defense counsel contended that D'Aust was asleep just prior to the incident and that there was no proof she was ever conscious before her death. He contended that, if she did suffer, it would have been for a very short amount of time.
RESULT After the jury's third day of deliberations, the parties negotiated a settlement. The defendant's insurer agreed to pay $190,000.
PLAINTIFF EXPERT(S) |
Jeffrey M. Levine, M.D., geriatrics, |
|
New York, NY |
DEFENSE EXPERT(S) |
Bruce Naughton, M.D., geriatrics,
|
|
Buffalo, NY
|
EDITOR'S NOTE
This report is based on information that was provided by plaintiff's counsel. Defense counsel did not respond to the reporter's phone calls. -Tim Heinz
Verdict Resources
----------------------------
Access our easy-to-useverdict and settlement database
----------------------------------------
www.verdictsearch.com